Website Suggestion for Mr. QuFox

[Josue_Gordon]

Minecraft username:

Josue_Gordon​

Suggestion:

Suggestion for Mr. QuFox​

Detailed description:

As we already know, most of the suggestions on the forums are handled by Mr. QuFox, respected developer of the Pika Network and the Game Producer. He accepts/rejects a suggestion based on how unique the suggestion is and how it will impact the server. However, sometimes, he denies the suggestion, which is unique and original. And instead of giving a proper reason to deny it, he uses the same respond everytime while denying a suggestion.

Screenshot

Captured with Lightshot

prnt.sc

This is the response he uses every time to deny a suggestion, even though when a suggestion is unique, this response doesn't really clarify much why the suggestion was denied in the first place. Players are left on a cliffhanger that their suggestion was unique and cool, but it got denied with no proper explaination but just a copied and pasted response of every denied suggestion.

My suggestion to Mr. QuFox Sir: We know you deny the suggestion for a reason, but whenever you are denying a suggestion that is cool, unique, and has so many upvotes to it, please give a proper reason for denying it in the first place rather than using the same response again and again for denying every suggestion.​

Reason(s):

I am not asking for a proper reason for every suggestion, but please provide a clear reason for denying a cool, unique, and highly upvoted suggestion. This won't leave the suggestion maker, the people who upvoted it, and the people who commented about it on a cliffhanger that why their suggestion was denied. With your proper reason, it would help the suggestion maker to understand why the suggestion was denied, even though it was upvoted by a lot of people. This would help them to make a better suggestion in the future, which you might actually accept it.​

Example(s):

Example: This suggestion for Improvement in the Swear Filter System, this suggestion was pretty good, and people agreed with it and upvoted it, but still it got denied with the same reason as all the suggestions normally get denied.
Your same reasons do not really help the community and the suggestion maker understand why the suggestion got denied, what was lacking in their suggestion, and what resulted in the denial of the suggestion.
Still, I am not saying to necessarily respond to all the suggestions, it would take a lot of time, and we know you have hundreds of suggestions to handle and a lot of work as well, but at least those suggestions which are unique, upvoted by people, and have positive response from the community, you should give a proper reason for denying. I hope you consider my request
Thank you​

 

[Bumbrah]

I understand the frustration, but he already clearly stated that he can't reply to thousands of suggestion with a proper reason. He also stated that it's a time consuming work when you deny hundreds of suggestions and provide a valid reason along with denied suggestions. Hence, to save time he uses that macro, and one of the denial reason(s) would match that why was that particular suggestion denied.

 

[Josue_Gordon]

I understand the frustration, but he already clearly stated that he can't reply to thousands of suggestion with a proper reason. He also stated that it's a time consuming work when you deny hundreds of suggestions and provide a valid reason along with denied suggestions. Hence, to save time he uses that macro, and one of the denial reason(s) would match that why was that particular suggestion denied.

That's what I mentioned in my suggestion. Those suggestions who got good amount of upvotes, positive response from the community and are very unique, should deserve a proper response for denying them. Not all suggestion deserve proper denial reason, but this doesn't justify with the unique suggestions poeple come up with.

 

[Bumbrah]

That's what I mentioned in my suggestion. Those suggestions who got good amount of upvotes, positive response from the community and are very unique, should deserve a proper response for denying them. Not all suggestion deserve proper denial reason, but this doesn't justify with the unique suggestions poeple come up with.

He does reply sometimes, when he denies and accepts suggestions. At the end of the day, it's all his wish.

 

[Rehan_Gamer416]

I Understand that but He is a Human Not a Machine , It will Take so much time to Make a proper reason and What will u do with a proper reason when ur suggestion is denaid.

 

[DeepStrikerX]

They have to go through a lot of suggestions, so it’s not always possible to give detailed replies to each one. Also, they are busy working on new seasons and adding new features that players enjoy.

Even if a suggestion is unique, they have to think about balance and long-term impact. So decisions may feel short, but they are made after proper consideration.

 

[EpicMiner001]

DeepStrikerX is right. The developers handle many suggestions while also working hard on updates and new content for players. Even if replies are short, their effort and decisions deserve respect.

 

[Josue_Gordon]

DeepStrikerX is right. The developers handle many suggestions while also working hard on updates and new content for players. Even if replies are short, their effort and decisions deserve respect.

I don't think you are still getting my point at all. I have already mentioned that they have to deal with so many suggestions, and they have a lot of work as well. I mentioned that they don't necessarily have to respond to every suggestion with proper reasoning. Those suggestions that have positive feedback from the community, which is unique and upvoted by many people, if such suggestions get denied, then only they can give a proper reason for denying them. Not all suggestions deserve proper reasoning. Please read my whole suggestion before commenting on anything. I have already mentioned the problems and their solution; this is the 3rd time I am addressing the same thing

 

[Josue_Gordon]

I Understand that but He is a Human Not a Machine , It will Take so much time to Make a proper reason and What will u do with a proper reason when ur suggestion is denaid.

By giving a proper reason to a good suggestion, which was actually good and unique, upvoted by many people, the player/community can understand properly where they are lacking in the suggestion, which resulted in the denial of the suggestion. This would help the players make even better, more useful suggestions in the future that will have a higher chance of getting accepted.

 

[EpicMiner001]

I don't think you are still getting my point at all. I have already mentioned that they have to deal with so many suggestions, and they have a lot of work as well. I mentioned that they don't necessarily have to respond to every suggestion with proper reasoning. Those suggestions that have positive feedback from the community, which is unique and upvoted by many people, if such suggestions get denied, then only they can give a proper reason for denying them. Not all suggestions deserve proper reasoning. Please read my whole suggestion before commenting on anything. I have already mentioned the problems and their solution; this is the 3rd time I am addressing the same thing

Your point is understood, but even highly upvoted or unique suggestions still need to be evaluated on technical feasibility, balance, and long-term impact. A suggestion having support doesn’t always mean it fits the server’s direction.

At the end, the team decides based on what works best overall, not just on popularity or uniqueness.

 

[ProDeaths__]

That's what I mentioned in my suggestion. Those suggestions who got good amount of upvotes, positive response from the community and are very unique, should deserve a proper response for denying them. Not all suggestion deserve proper denial reason, but this doesn't justify with the unique suggestions poeple come up with.

they do
he gives proper reason if the community took interest and in that suggestion and was supported by many

 

[Methovas]

Neutral
Sometimes giving a reason when it is possible would be very good for improvements, I agree with that. But only if it actually fits, because the suggestion was good or something has to be said, or similar reasons.

Example:
------------
... has been decided to deny your suggestion.

Note:

• Too ressource intensive
  

Have fun playing on PikaNetwork
-----------