Website Accepted Suggestions Update

[ieoub]

Minecraft username:

ieoub​

Suggestion:

Suggestions Update​

Detailed description:

a lot of members are posting tons of random or low-effort suggestions just to get the gold reward when one gets accepted.
Sometimes people even post stuff that should really be a bug report or ticket, not a suggestion. and also, instead of providing all the similar ideas in one post they decide to split it into multiple small ones, just to increase their chances of getting more gold. and I can provide a lot of these people and their posts but let's keep it anonymous

I get why people do it, but it kind of floods the section and makes it harder for the devs to find good, creative ideas. it feels like a gold farming section. especially lately. sometimes you can see a fresh creative suggestion that the poster provided a neccessary thing but you can see someone down voted it. it's like competing against each others

My Idea :

Instead of giving gold automatically when a suggestion gets accepted, maybe make it based on the quality of the suggestion.
For example:

• The dev who accepts it could decide if it deserves a reward or not. and what priority
• If it’s really creative or detailed
• If it’s just a simple or already-known idea, maybe no rewards at all.

This would encourage players to focus more on quality over quantity and post all their ideas together instead of spamming 10 small ones.​

Reason(s):

I made this post because I’ve noticed that the current suggestion reward system is being abused by some members who just spam random or low-quality ideas to earn gold. This ends up:

• Filling the section with too many useless or repeated posts,
• Making it harder for staff or member to find actual good suggestions to upvote or interact with
• Discouraging members who take time to write detailed, helpful ideas.

My goal with this post is to make the suggestion section fairer and cleaner, and to reward players who actually put effort and creativity into their ideas.​

Example(s):

devs can have a macro to select the priority of that accepted suggestion :

Priority	Name	Description	Example Gold Reward
Priority 1	Basic Idea	Simple or small suggestion, already known or minor change	0
Priority 2	Helpful Idea	Useful suggestion with some thought put into it	15 Gold
Priority 3	Creative Idea	Original idea that could improve gameplay or community	30 Gold
Priority 4	Major Improvement	Detailed suggestion that adds noticeable value or new features	60 Gold
Priority 5	Exceptional Suggestion	Very unique, well-written, and impactful idea that helps the whole server	100+ Gold

instead of the accepted message :

Hi {thread_author},
Thank you for your interest in creating a suggestion for the server.
I am glad to inform you that your suggestion has been accepted and is either already implemented or will be implemented soon.

I suggest making it like this :
Hi {thread_author},
Thank you for your interest in creating a suggestion for the server.
I am glad to inform you that your suggestion has been accepted as {?+PriorityLevel} suggestion and will be implemented soon.

for @Arrly
instead of posting Suggestions Gold with
Format: [Minecraft username] - [the amount of gold they received]

it can be Suggestion Confirmation with :
Format: [Minecraft username] - [2x Priority 4, 3x Priority 3] - [Total Gold]​

 

[Deadsoul125]

+1 its like the skymines auction house tax system. ngl the ah feels better with tax since no1 puts useless sht for gold now

 

[Deadsoul125]

how do i give this a vote???

 

[ieoub]

+1 its like the skymines auction house tax system. ngl the ah feels better with tax since no1 puts useless sht for gold now

me too I loved the gold tax

how do i give this a vote???

to upvote or down vote a suggestion, you see the arrows in the top right of each suggestion posts: ( ↑ - ↓ )

 

[Surbate]

This is already a thing, refer to the changelog:

 

[ieoub]

This is already a thing, refer to the changelog:

View attachment 131995

ik, but it became too much, especially the splitting. for example alot of suggestions should be counted as one. let's take this post as example :
it could be cutted to multiple posts - 1 suggestions cooldown, 2 - suggestions priorities, 3- suggestions payouts update to fit suggestions prioriities, 4- unique suggestions more rewards ... etc, isntead of providing them all in one I could just post as many as possible

 

[EpicMiner001]

Minecraft username:

ieoub​

Suggestion:

Suggestions Update​

Detailed description:

a lot of members are posting tons of random or low-effort suggestions just to get the gold reward when one gets accepted.​

Sometimes people even post stuff that should really be a bug report or ticket, not a suggestion. and also, instead of providing all the similar ideas in one post they decide to split it into multiple small ones, just to increase their chances of getting more gold. and I can provide a lot of these people and their posts but let's keep it anonymous​

​

I get why people do it, but it kind of floods the section and makes it harder for the devs to find good, creative ideas. it feels like a gold farming section. especially lately. sometimes you can see a fresh creative suggestion that the poster provided a neccessary thing but you can see someone down voted it. it's like competing against each others ​

​

My Idea :​

​

Instead of giving gold automatically when a suggestion gets accepted, maybe make it based on the quality of the suggestion.​

For example:​

​

• The dev who accepts it could decide if it deserves a reward or not. and what priority
• If it’s really creative or detailed
• If it’s just a simple or already-known idea, maybe no rewards at all.

This would encourage players to focus more on quality over quantity and post all their ideas together instead of spamming 10 small ones.​

Reason(s):

I made this post because I’ve noticed that the current suggestion reward system is being abused by some members who just spam random or low-quality ideas to earn gold. This ends up:​

​

• Filling the section with too many useless or repeated posts,
• Making it harder for staff or member to find actual good suggestions to upvote or interact with
• Discouraging members who take time to write detailed, helpful ideas.

My goal with this post is to make the suggestion section fairer and cleaner, and to reward players who actually put effort and creativity into their ideas.​

Example(s):

devs can have a macro to select the priority of that accepted suggestion : ​

​

Priority	Name	Description	Example Gold Reward
Priority 1	Basic Idea	Simple or small suggestion, already known or minor change	0
Priority 2	Helpful Idea	Useful suggestion with some thought put into it	15 Gold
Priority 3	Creative Idea	Original idea that could improve gameplay or community	30 Gold
Priority 4	Major Improvement	Detailed suggestion that adds noticeable value or new features	60 Gold
Priority 5	Exceptional Suggestion	Very unique, well-written, and impactful idea that helps the whole server	100+ Gold

​

​

instead of the accepted message : ​

​

Hi {thread_author},​

Thank you for your interest in creating a suggestion for the server.​

I am glad to inform you that your suggestion has been accepted and is either already implemented or will be implemented soon.​

​

I suggest making it like this : ​

Hi {thread_author},​

Thank you for your interest in creating a suggestion for the server.​

I am glad to inform you that your suggestion has been accepted as {?+PriorityLevel} suggestion and will be implemented soon.​

​

for @Arrly ​

instead of posting Suggestions Gold with​

Format: [Minecraft username] - [the amount of gold they received]​

​

it can be Suggestion Confirmation with :​

Format: [Minecraft username] - [2x Priority 4, 3x Priority 3] - [Total Gold]​

-1 They know how much gold they should give,and not too many suggestions are accepted , it is denied too, good suggestions has been accepted,and about gold it should be same like going now,no need to change.

 

[EpicMiner001]

ik, but it became too much, especially the splitting. for example alot of suggestions should be counted as one. let's take this post as example :
it could be cutted to multiple posts - 1 suggestions cooldown, 2 - suggestions priorities, 3- suggestions payouts update to fit suggestions prioriities, 4- unique suggestions more rewards ... etc, isntead of providing them all in one I could just post as many as possible

It is not taken as in one way if it is not that affective you will receive 100 gold,and if it's good you can get 100+